I am just wondering why the elves were leaving middle earth and also why did Bilbo and Frodo and Gandalf had to leave middle earth for ever? Now I know that elves were leaving middle earth since around the 1st age, by the way I know nothing of The Silmirillion (I think its a bad spelling). But does anyone know why the elves had to leave middle earth for ever? Its one of the big themes of lotr and tolkiens myths, that the elves were leaving middle earth and leaving the men to get on with it. But why would the elves leave when there still so much danger in the world, they knew sauron was still present, and a real threat to the status quo.

Nicely one truth that provides been unsuccessful to become mentioned about the elf rings will be that the elves in fact only possess 2 of their rings of power.gandalf offers the third band of strength and has since his appeared in middle earth.mainly because far as why thé elves are Ieaving their tired of the ignorance of males the wars and the world being demolished. So as all elves exhausted of the globe they can leave so instead of indulging in a battle that has a 99% opportunity of heading against them and them becoming slaves they decided to go with to leave.

Numenor had been the ancestors of gondor therefore human. It will be pretty complicated question as tó why the eIves are leaving middIe earth. The method i recognize it longer ago the elves were known as to valinor (whére they are aIl leaving for, house of the gods) almost all took the voyage and resided with them for age range. Nicely one of the gods stole some gems that had been very valuable to the eIves (or atleast oné of them) pIus numerous elves desired realms of their very own like as galadriel. Therefore there was a excellent exodus back to middle earth to fight the evil capabilities that be. Well back again to LOTR those malignant forces are about to accomplish final success or the best defeat, so one of the major puposes to the elves becoming there is certainly about at an end and they are becoming called back again to valinor.

Generally this will be the method i get it. Theres a great deal more to it, but i have got dumbed it down to maintain this write-up from working on forever and i hope that some of the info isnt altered in the effort. Right, the Elves real time in Middle-Earth ended at the finish of Second Age in the big fight we saw at the begin of the first film. This had been called the Last Connections- not because guy and Elf would never ever be buddy again, but because after that fight the Elves would simply no longer exist as a true lifestyle on Middle-Eárth as the bulk of them would end up being going west.It must end up being valued that these lands to the Western world are the real home of MOST óf these Elves. Somé of them aré descended from tjhosé who just came back again to Middle-Eárth in an attempt to battle wicked (and obtained stuck generally there much longer than prepared), some are déscended from those whó by no means produced it out West- but ALWAYS meant to move there.

Just a specific line of Elves (identified as 'Avari', or 'Refusers') certainly not really had much attention in heading.This lengthy delayed move back west happened at the start of the Third Age group. And it was conceptually important as well- the 3 rd Age is certainly the Age group where Guy takes the lead, not really Elves. And the 4th Age to come after the Battle of the Band is a modern age group, where immortal creatures like the Elves no longer belong.BUT.

Some Elves do stay for the Third Age, of training course. Some, like Galadriel, got particualr attachment to their homes. Elrond sensed a responsibility for managing the fledgling human kingdoms since the problems of the damage of Numenor. Cirdan, I think, remained in the Gray Havens just so he could oversee the transfer of Elves wishing to keep (Elves going west catch a ship from the Havéns).Eavh of thése three Elven debt settlements, then, symbolizes a bastion of the aged times, funds that no bad can touch until Sauron will get his Band back again where the outdated Elves still live.

More significantly, each of these three took cost of one óf the Three EIvish Bands. These Rings could not be delivered west and SOMEONE, of course, had to appear after them. It is certainly on the strength of these Bands that the safety and energy of the Elvish Havens was taken care of- though to his credit, Cirdan basically gave his to Gandalf.Today, when the One Ring is ruined, that strength goes. These last bastions of genuine Elvish energy will diminish without that strength- and those EIves in them whó remained behind know that their period is lastly arrive after all, ánd they must go. THIS can be why the final of the Elves are producing prepared to leave at the time of the movies.However, there are a few exclusions. The Large Elves (Noldor) may nicely be heading, mainly because will many of the Sindar (Grey Elves- pretty very much the 'regular' Elf).

However, there is definitely nevertheless a Sindar Empire in the Mirkwóod (of whom LegoIas' dad is Full, who, btw, locked up the Dwarvvés and BiIbo in The Hóbbit) whose population possess no cause to go- Legoloas only will go because he feels the calling of the sea but the sleep have no want to. And there are plenty of Avari (most of whom aré Silvan, or Wóod Elves) close to in the spread jungles (and furthermore in the Mirkwood) who have no reason to proceed possibly. So there may however become some remnant óf the Elves, actually though the suggestion is certainly that the time for immortal beings on Middle-Earth offers long gone.BTW, whilst a glimmer of potential future prediction is certainly indeed a noted capability of powerful Elves (and actually some Dunadain, such as Malbeth thé Seer and actually the father of Boromir ánd Faramir (didn'capital t do him very much great though)), when Elrond 'predicted' that Aragorn had been heading to perish, he was only making use of his common feeling- Aragorn is certainly human! Hey ush, didnt celeborn keep in middle earth? Someplace i though i noticed that he remained in lorien for awhile after that transferred to rivendale where elronds sons remand, then who understands what. Kind of can make no sense to me, hes got this supreme hottie and they are moving to live in a place of happiness and no concerns, yet he remains in middle éarth.

I kind óf think of thé 4tl age as the age group that all the remaining races kind of change out. The elves that are left over, the dwarvés, ents, and thé hobbits, leaving man the singular inhabiter of M.At the. Wow.excellent explanation from Ushgarak.I think I got confused by the film in fact.In the theatrical launch of L0TR:TTT.at thé battle of helm'beds heavy.it showed reinforcements in the type of elves brought by Haldir being released on the to support the people in the upcoming fight.but in real fact this do not happen in the book do it? Has been the fight of helm't heavy in the guide was fought against by humans alone?I think this is certainly the component which baffled me.cos I has been wondering why the elves were talking about leaving ánd everything and then on the other hand send an military of elves to aid the human beings at helm's deep.

Zero, in fact, in the publication the elves did not come to the help of Róhan in TTT. Anothér thing is certainly that Eomer has been currently at Helm's i9000 Heavy with Aragorn, LegoIas, Gimli, Theoden ánd the several hundred males defending the fortress. Gandalf emerged with a different Rohan Lieutenant called Erkenbrand. Plus, the reinforcements had been not on race horses, but on feet.

That'h why it got so long for them to get there. It has been great though in the film to see all the horses cycling down that high slope, wasn'testosterone levels it?The elves do not show up much in the books. In reality, the just elves we are observed to have struggled are Legolas ánd Elrond's double sons. Nevertheless, the elves had been not just sitting down around performing nothing.

Lothlorien was under constant strike, so they could not deliver any aid. Rivendell is usually but a small region. In truth, it's only the dimension of a city, so they could not afford to send aid. Maintain in mind this is a middle-earth 'town', and not one like Néw York with 20 kadrillion ppl.The elves are leaving because they possess lingered in Middle earth as well long currently. They had been summoned at the beginning of the Initial Age group, and they have got already stayed Two Ages too lengthy, which will be at minimum 6000+ yrs.

As somebody mentioned previous, the Noldor arrived back again to Middle-earth after going to Valinor (The only significant Noldarian elf remaining is Galadriel, thus why she is definitely much wiser than all additional elves. In evaluation, she will be an whole Age older than Elrond) Nevertheless, after the actions of the Guys of Numenor in the early Second Age, Valinor has been taken apart from the circles of Arda (the planet). That is definitely why no one can come back from Valinor once they move presently there.

It is usually also not a basic ship journey across to obtain generally there, but just elves are permitted to proceed since they have been called forth. Gimli got to go because he had been most effective buds with LegoIas, and Frodo got to go because he has been a ringbearer, and the ring inspired him too significantly while he had it.

Gandalf got to go because he is definitely returning house to become a Maiar again. Some interesting information for those óf you who havén't study the Silmirallion:1.Gandalfs real name is definitely Olorin.2.Saruman's actual name can be Curunir signifying guy of ability.3.Sauron had been once a servant of an also greater evil Melkor or Mórgoth as he was called by the eIves.4.The Lord of Middle Earth can be Eru or Illuvatar. He made the Ainur including Melkor.5.The wizards are in fact the Istari, made by the Ainur and sent to Middle Earth to assist the people beat Sauron.6.Wchicken Gandalfs comes back in the Twó Towers it is definitely not obviously explained how. What happened was that when he passed away the Ainur offered him a new entire body and delivered him back to Center Planet.7.Galadriel can be Elrond'beds great great aunt and mothér-in-law.8.If you have noticed the film you'll understand how massive and powerful a Balrog can be. Well simply to give you an idea of the range of the SiImarillion imagine a little military of Balrogs, properly that's specifically what Melkor has.9.For individuals who possess study the LOTR but not the Silmarillion and know about shelob and how outdated and strong she is certainly visualize her mother (whose name goes out me at the instant) who grew so effective that Melkor had been chased across Center Earth by her and would possess been slain until his Balrog't rescued him. That'h correct Hegemon875. I have examine it =G and Unfinished Tales simply because properly.Those tales will 'explain to' ppl and will show the bigger image of the planet.

Each Age weighing scales down in terms of heroism, power, and fights. Just think about the fifth great battle of the First Age group, aka the Battle of Unnumbered Cry. It had, on the aspect of good:1. Tens of hundreds of Elves: aIl the Noldor thát acquired returned to Center Earth directed by their princes.2. Males: Had just began arriving into their very own in Beleriand and had been allied with thé elves.3.

Dwarves, although their quantities were restricted compared to the eIves.On the side of malignant, there had been WAY even more enemies than in lotr:1. 100s of hundreds of orcs.2.

Bad men, and some were even initially allies of thé elves, but converted on them as soon as the fight obtained under method.3. 100s of Balrogs, brought by Gothmog the almost all effective4. Lastly, big unpleasant Dragons, business lead by the first Dragon Glaurung. Posted by aragorn1: 'you know what i dont obtain is definitely why people cant come back again from valinor or gray havens?' Wow.i think i simply spent 30 minutes. Reading all of thát!!

Oh weIl.i didn'capital t understand that the aid that was sent was on foot.i believed they acquired race horses, but it required so lengthy to get presently there because they had been a LONG way away. I've aIl three LotR publications.and i desire to go through the hobbit, ánd i've héard of the siImarillion.but never got around to reading it!

But thanks for informing me! Some of the stuff in these films/books are confusing just from the stage of it will get into information i dón't undérstand. And after that to move along with that, the films aren't consistant and wear't clarify enough, like the publications. Although, i don'capital t mind looking at orlando blossom for 3 hours at a time!! Okay, we are obtaining a lot of 'superior mindset' posting by those who have read Incomplete Reports and ther Silmarillion- I think that can be toned down.Especially by those who take them as totally truthful. They are N0T. Christopher Tolkien spécifies that they aré Incomplete works (hence the name of the second one, yes?) and are just guidelines, not facts.

Tolkien under no circumstances designed them for publication and they were always in flux.The Balrog number is definitely a point in reality- a poster confidently claims there were '100s' of Balrogs. Incorrect- Turin smartly concerns it. Christopher Tolkien obviously states- factually and unequivocally- that his father chose on a last amount of 7. So before you start reeling off facts to people to look informed, people should examine their own.People require to be very, really cautious about these items. Also the Silmarillion is definitely bogus; and everything else other than the four main books can be is almost entirely speculative. Wow, kind of a little severe, but genuine.

I dont know if it can be a exceptional attitude simply everybody is certainly pretty confident in what they understand. Many stuff that people consider as reality arent, credited to as ush place it the constant condition of flux aIl of it had been in. Generally the best way to approach this things will be reader be put on, there are a great deal of individuals that understand there files right here, but the best way will be to find out on your personal and supliment it with individuals understanding in right here.

Thats my viewpoint anyways. Heres what i do (to include my ass) whenever i condition something i start off by saying i beleive, unless i possess the books sitting correct infront of mé.contd from over.Anyways, so, the Elves are moving from Center earth, it is certainly often mentioned, 'They complete to the west'. I have got been reading through a great deal about the history of this tale on various sites.

I have got not learn any of the books yet, but I program to. I simply wished to include my two cents right here. I have noticed the prolonged version of The Two Towers. There were many moments that transferred me.

But, this one really got me. The picture where Treebeard can be singing to Merry ánd Pippin while walking through the timber. This will be the music he sung tó them:Beneath thé roof of resting leavesAnd the desires of trees and shrubs unfoldWhen the woodland halls are natural and coolAnd the breeze is definitely in the westCome back to me! (inhales as taking first breath)Come back again to me!And state my property is usually bestThe words, scenery, songs, and the idea that the elves were the types who woke up the trees but are today leaving, had been almost too much to allow myself sense.

Well, to pick a nit, nó elves could move Western after the fourth age group, because the 4th age can be still heading on.However, I know what you designed. I believe it's possible that there had been several eIves in M-E during thé first few generations after the begin of the 4th age. After all, LegoIas didn't go until after Aragorn't death, even more than a century after the end of LótR. Why would hé end up being the just elf to remain on so long, or the last to leave?However, in the appéndix, after Aragorn passed away Arwen came back to Lorien for a time; Galadriel and Celeborn had been both gone, and 'the land was quiet'.

This indicates that she had been alone - that all the some other elves of Lorien got already departed as well.